Springs Bath Remodel (719) 466-8828

Losing the Tub Won't Tank Your Resale: Tub-to-Shower Conversion Myths in Colorado Springs

Roughly two-thirds of U.S. households say they shower far more often than they take a bath, and in many homes the tub goes months without a drop of water in it. That gap matters here, because a tub-to-shower conversion is one of the most requested bathroom changes in Colorado Springs and El Paso County, and it is also the one wrapped in the most stubborn myths. Homeowners put it off for years over worries that turn out to be half-true at best.

Let’s take the five beliefs we hear most often and sort what’s real from what’s just repeated.

Myth 1: Ripping Out the Tub Kills Your Resale

The idea that every house needs a tub to sell is the single most common reason people hesitate. It is mostly outdated. What actually moves buyers is having at least one usable bathing option somewhere in the home, not a tub in every bathroom.

A realistic example: say a Colorado Springs homeowner has a three-bedroom house with a cramped tub in the primary bath and a second full bath with a tub down the hall. Converting the primary to a roomy walk-in shower while keeping the hall tub often reads as an upgrade to buyers, not a loss. Families who want a tub still have one.

Where the old advice holds is a single-bathroom home. If you only have one bathroom, keeping a tub (or choosing a shower-tub combo) protects the widest pool of buyers. We cover that exact tradeoff in deciding what survives a full bathroom remodel.

Myth 2: A Conversion Always Means Moving the Plumbing

Plenty of homeowners assume that swapping a tub for a shower means tearing into the floor and rerouting pipes, which sounds expensive and disruptive. Often it isn’t.

A standard alcove tub already has a drain and a water supply in roughly the right zone. When the crew keeps the shower in the same footprint, the drain frequently shifts only a short distance, and sometimes the supply lines barely move at all. That keeps the job cleaner and faster.

Moving plumbing becomes necessary when you change the layout, say pushing the shower to a different wall, widening the opening into a neighboring closet, or switching from a center drain to a linear drain along one edge. Those are design choices, not automatic requirements. A good contractor will tell you upfront which path your bathroom falls into before any demo starts.

Myth 3: It’s a Weeks-Long Mess Either Way

Here is where the biggest range lives, and why blanket timelines are misleading. “Conversion” covers two very different projects.

A straightforward acrylic or solid-surface swap, where the crew removes the tub and installs new walls and a base in the same footprint, is often wrapped up in a few working days. A full tile rebuild, with new waterproofing, custom tile, a bench, and a niche, runs longer because tile and mortar need cure time and the work is done by hand.

A realistic example: a homeowner wanting a low-maintenance, quick turnaround might choose an acrylic system and be showering again within the week. A homeowner wanting a fully tiled, curbless design should plan for a longer stretch and a bit more dust. Neither is “wrong,” they are different products. If living through the work worries you, the piece on getting through a remodel without trashing the rest of your house is worth a read.

Myth 4: A Walk-In Shower Means a Slippery, Unsafe Floor

Some homeowners picture a wide-open shower and imagine a skating rink, especially if they are converting partly for aging-in-place reasons. Done right, a converted shower is usually safer than the tub it replaced.

Think about what you’re removing: a tall tub wall you have to swing a leg over, often with wet feet and nothing to grab. Replacing that with a low or zero-threshold entry, slip-resistant floor tile or a textured base, and a properly anchored grab bar is a net safety gain. The key words are “properly anchored.” Grab bars need blocking behind the wall, and slope has to send water to the drain so it doesn’t pool. Those are build details, not luck.

Myth 5: You Lose Too Much Usable Space

People often assume a shower feels smaller than the tub footprint it sits in. In practice, a standard alcove tub is about 60 inches long and 30 to 32 inches deep, which is a generous footprint for a shower. Reclaim that full area and the showering space usually feels larger, not smaller, because you are no longer stepping into a basin.

The space myth runs the other direction too: some worry a bigger shower demands a bigger room. It doesn’t. The footprint is already there. What changes is how open it feels once the tub wall is gone and glass or a half-wall replaces it.

Where to Start in Colorado Springs

If one tub in your home sits unused, a conversion is usually easier, faster, and friendlier to resale than the myths suggest. The honest first step is a plan: which bath to convert, whether the plumbing moves, and which product fits how you actually live. You can see who serves the Colorado Springs area or get matched with a local bathroom remodeler for a free in-home design consult to walk your specific layout.

Frequently Asked Questions

We only have one bathroom. Is a conversion off the table? Not necessarily, but it changes the smart choice. In a single-bathroom home, many homeowners keep bathing possible with a shower-tub combo or a deep shower that can accommodate a future seat, rather than removing all bathing capacity. It protects resale and daily flexibility at the same time.

Can an upstairs tub be converted, or is the second floor a problem? Second-floor conversions are common. The main considerations are drain access from below and proper waterproofing, since a leak upstairs reaches the ceiling beneath it. A contractor will check joist direction and existing drain routing before committing to a layout.

What if I want to convert now but might sell in a few years? Lean toward broadly appealing finishes and keep at least one tub in the home if you can. A clean, neutral walk-in shower with good lighting and slip-resistant flooring tends to photograph and show well. If budget timing is the real question, the guide on funding a bathroom remodel without draining savings lays out the options.

Have a question in Colorado Springs?

We will take a look and give you a straight answer, free.

Call (719) 466-8828